Aviation Insurance Blogs

Aircraft Liability – Legal Defense

Author

Tim Bonnell

Date Published

Illustration: judge's gavel and an airplane on a navy-to-blue background

When you buy aircraft liability coverage, the liability limit isn't the only thing you're buying. You're also buying a legal defense. In most aircraft insurance policies, the insurance company defends suits against you and pays the defense costs outside the policy limits, until those limits are used up by judgments and settlements.

How aircraft liability coverage and legal defense work

The Insuring Agreements section of the policy specifies that the insurance company has a duty and a right to defend any suit against the insured seeking damages for bodily injury or property damage, even if any of the allegations of the suit are groundless, false, or fraudulent.

Two parts of that sentence are worth slowing down for:

  • Duty to defend. The insurer defends covered suits at its expense. Because it also has the right to defend, it generally selects and directs defense counsel.
  • Even if the allegations are groundless. A suit doesn't have to have merit to be defended. Groundless, false or fraudulent allegations still cost money to answer, and the policy responds to them.

Your aviation insurers work with very knowledgeable aviation defense attorneys, which matters in a field where the technical and regulatory details often decide a case.

What does "defense outside the limits" mean?

In most aircraft insurance policies, the legal defense expenses are paid outside of the policy limits. The cost to defend the claim is not deducted from the limits available for judgments and settlements.

Example: You carry $1,000,000 of liability coverage and defending the lawsuit costs $1,000,000. Your $1,000,000 limit is still fully available to pay a judgment or settlement, because defense costs and damages are two separate levels of expense.

Not every policy works this way, so confirm how defense costs are treated in your own policy wording.

Most aircraft insurance policies and aviation commercial general liability policies provide for the defense costs outside the limit of liability.

What do defense costs include?

Defense costs go beyond attorney fees. They will likely pay for:

  • The defense attorneys
  • Expert witnesses
  • Some bail bonds, if necessary

The exact list of what is paid, sometimes called supplementary payments, is set out in the policy. Read that section with your broker.

When does the insurer's duty to defend end?

The insurance company's duty to defend ends when it has exhausted the limits of the policy with judgments and settlements.

That is one of the key reasons to carry adequate liability limits. A limit that looks comfortable for one claim can be used up quickly by a serious occurrence, and once it is, the insurer's obligation to keep defending ends with it. For how to think about the right number, see How Much Aviation Liability Insurance Does a Business Need?

Severability of interest: a separate defense for each insured

The Severability of Interest clause provides a separate legal defense for each insured. If a suit names several insureds, each is entitled to a separate defense, subject to coverage and the limits.

Keep in mind, however, that the company's duty to defend still ends when the policy limits have been exhausted by the payment of judgments and settlements.

Why multiple insureds can use up the limit

When there are multiple insureds, the first insured's case to settle could exhaust the policy limits, ending the company's duty to defend the remaining insureds.

Policies often have more insureds than owners realize. Depending on the policy wording, more people than the Named Insured may be insureds, and contracts such as hangar leases often require that an airport, FBO or other party be added as an additional insured. See Named Insured vs. Additional Insured in Aviation Insurance and Should Your Insurer Review Hangar Leases and Service Contracts?

The total number of insureds must be kept in mind when selecting a liability limit, so that there are plenty of liability limits in place to allow for the continued legal defense of all applicable insureds.

Questions to ask your broker

  • Are defense costs paid outside my liability limit?
  • Who are all the insureds under my policy, including additional insureds required by contracts?
  • If several insureds are sued for one occurrence, is my limit high enough to keep all of them defended?
  • What supplementary payments, such as expert witnesses or bail bonds, does my policy include?

Frequently asked questions

Will my insurer defend a lawsuit that has no merit?

Yes, for a covered claim. The policy gives the insurer a duty to defend suits seeking damages for bodily injury or property damage, even if the allegations are groundless, false, or fraudulent.

Do legal defense costs reduce my liability limit?

In most aircraft insurance policies, no. Defense expenses are paid outside the policy limits, so they don't reduce the amount available for judgments and settlements. Confirm this in your own policy.

When does the insurance company stop defending me?

When the policy limits have been exhausted by the payment of judgments and settlements.

What is the Severability of Interest clause?

It provides a separate legal defense for each insured under the policy.

Why do multiple insureds matter when choosing a limit?

Because they share the same limit. The first insured's case to settle could exhaust it, ending the insurer's duty to defend everyone else.

Want your liability limit reviewed against your aircraft, contracts and insureds? Get started or call 844-422-0023.

DISCLAIMER: These articles are for educational purposes only and due to the changing regulatory and legal nature of this business, some information may change over time. Having a well-educated and experienced aviation insurance broker on your team is an absolute requirement to success in business and for managing your aircraft and aviation business risks.

Illustration: graduation cap and a crop sprout on a navy-to-blue background
Aviation Insurance Blogs

Learn how aerial application operators train and insure new pilots, meet experience requirements, manage liability limits, and transition from piston.